Most Forgiving Putters 2024

We hear a lot about forgiving drivers, woods and irons but less so with the flat-stick. This shouldn't be the case though because many brands construct extremely forgiving putters that will help your game. 

But what brands make the most forgiving putters? Well, the best putters for forgiveness are usually mallets designs. That's because mallet putters are heavier, have a big footprint and tend to be more stable as you putt. The centre of gravity is generally lower and spread out towards the extremities of the club head and away from the face. That allows players to hit a much more consistent and balanced stroke.  

The best mallet putters also tend to have a larger sweet spot which can be beneficial if you are a player who struggles to consistently strike your putts out of the middle of the face. The weight in the club-head also helps here, because it diminishes the twisting of the putter throughout the stroke too. This is what's known as the Moment of Inertia (MOI) and is an important factor to consider when picking out a new flat-stick.

Bearing all of this in mind, here are some of the most forgiving putters available on the market right now and are designed to get the ball rolling straight and true. Alternatively, if you are new to the game, you should also check out our guides on the best putters for beginners, or the best putters for high handicappers too.

WATCH: Joel Tadman runs through the best putters you can buy this year

The Quick List

Most Forgiving Putters

Top pick

To begin with, the INOVAI collection has four head options and, out of those four, it's the 6.5 which has the unorthodox shape. Aesthetically, it features a unique fang design that isn't like others on the market, with a sleeker and more compact look providing a premium feel and performance. 

But the forgiveness is where it further differentiates itself too. The hexagonal shape and fangs are designed to optimize the putter’s MOI (Moment of Inertia) thanks to triangular vents that save weight, which is then distributed to the perimeter to help provide stability and forgiveness. What's more, as it's built from 303 Stainless Steel front piece and a 6061 Military Grade Aluminum back section, we knew that we were getting consistent results time after time.

This showed up in our testing. The INOVAI sat nicely square and the alignment of the head is excellent, but again, the reason this is our top pick in this guide is its complete forgiveness. The high MOI was immediately obvious to us in the head feedback and the strike. When we did miss the center of the face there wasn’t a discernible difference in roll compared to when we found the middle, and the mishits travelled a very similar distance to the good strikes. 

• Read our full Bettinardi INOVAI 6.5 Putter Review

Best value

Wilson’s gear is underrated in most categories, with the brand's budget friendly prices perhaps giving a false impression of inferior products. That isn't the case at all and Wilson should be applauded for their excellence in the field of making golf more affordable. The same can be said of the putters in the current range.

The Bucktown is a mid-mallet, face-balanced putter that performed excellently for us in testing. Down at address the fang-shape frames the ball nicely and it sits very low to the ground flush to the grass. We liked the short white lines contrasting with the black head which really aided alignment. The two-tone PVD anti-glare finish certainly creates a visually-appealing look that adds to the premium feel.

Off the face, this putter has a solid, stable feel that comes from a subtle double mill pattern on the face. Acoustically it is at the higher end of the spectrum and it also gave a firm sensation which will marry well with a soft, low compression golf ball.

It's nice and forgiving too, which will music to the ears of the mid-to-high handicapper this putter is almost certainly aimed at.

• Read our full Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter Review

Best unique tech

So what’s new with this latest offering from Odyssey? Well the clue is in the name; Artificial Intelligence. Odyssey has now used the technology and super-computing capabilities of Callaway to create what it is calling “the most advanced insert in golf”. The multi-material construction includes unique contours on the back of the face that minimize ball speed losses on off-centre hits, and greatly increase the sweet spot. According to Odyssey, Ai-One leaves putts up to 21 percent closer to the hole.

But how did it test? Well the Rossie design is not as big and bulky as some of the other best mallet putters but we like the rounded shape and there is enough meat at the back of the head to warrant inclusion in this guide. From a feel standpoint, off the face it felt fantastic - buttery and responsive, whilst also producing a smooth, true roll. Distance control was easy as well. In terms of the forgiving technology, it was hard to specifically quantify but it certainly felt stable and consistent through impact.

Finally we should mention the navy PVD finish, which might be a little different to other designs out there, but it certainly has a very premium look.

• Read our full Odyssey Ai-One Rossie S Putter Review

Best face

We thoroughly enjoyed testing out the Cobra Vintage Cuda putter, especially when it comes to the face. It features a new PEBAX face insert crafted from lightweight and responsive thermo-plastic elastomer, which produces a soft feel. This then combines with Descending Loft Technology (DLT) on the face, which uses four descending lofts (4°, 3°, 2°, 1°) to maintain a consistent loft through impact regardless of your angle of attack or ball position in your stance. 

As a result we were extremely impressed in testing. The forgiveness was excellent, while the putter is responsive enough that you can feel when you've missed the sweet spot, but there is still a solidity about the strike that inspires confidence.

The presence of interchangeable weights was a bonus too so we could really dial in the weight and feel of the putter for the ultimate feel and control. You can also purchase additional weights of 5g, 10g, 15g, 20g and 25g in case you want a lighter or heavier head weight.

• Read our full Cobra King Vantage Cuda Putter review

Best looking

A customisable and stunning looking putter, the EV5 is the new flagship model of the brand, thanks t oits 3x3 versatility. It is a stunning club that is available in a variety of color combinations through three rear interchangeable chassis designs. You'll also be able to chose form six hosel options too. Evnroll have placed full customization into the hands of the golfer here with every visual preference and stroke type truly catered for. 

The EV5 is undoubtedly one of the most forgiving putters around. Despite being a compact mallet, the head feels more stable than previous Evnroll putters of a similar size and helped by the special grooves on the face, I was able to knock putts often to within gimmie range from long distance and scare the hole frequently from 20 feet and in. 

Regardless of how you build your EV5 putter, it will feature the unique groove technology engineered to deliver uniform performance across the entire hitting area. It uses a series of closely-spaced, variable-width channels that are wider in the centre and get gradually narrower toward the heel and toe. This creates a precisely calibrated inward V-shape that progressively redirects the ball down the target line.

• Read our full Evnroll EV5 2023 Putter Review

Best adjustability

Next we have the TaylorMade Spider GT Max putter which is one of the most adjustable putters on this list. It comes with plenty of versatility, with this stylish and innovative offering looking the part on the course too. It has a very cool sci-fi design that will sits large behind the golf ball. That all combines to deliver confidence inspiring club that many players will enjoy.

It does offer up a very similar design to the Spider GT, another forgiving putter, that also uses the same Pure Roll 2 insert that you'll find here. It delivers an excellent sound and feedback when you strike the golf ball and feels great even when you don't strike the ball out of the middle.  

But the weighting system on the sole is the main stand out feature here. It allows players to fine tune the CG placement and toe hang of the club through two 40g tungsten weights that sit on the wings of the club. You can move both to three different positions to try and achieve the ideal balance. Despite the variations being quite subtle, we noticed how the weights aided forgiveness by helping with consistency of shot production. 

• Read our full TaylorMade Spider GT Max Putter Review

Best premium model

The 2024 range of Scotty Cameron mallets has seen the brand go for a more futuristic look under the stewardship of design guru Austi Rollinson, who helped design some of the best Odyssey putters for over 25 years before making the switch to Scotty Cameron.

The Phantom 9 is a mid-sized, angular mallet putter with two cavities and a dual line alignment system, meaning this is a pretty drastic departure from what we’ve seen before among the best Scotty Cameron putters. There are two neck options to choose from but both have new shaft designs that mean the bends always point down the target line.

Behind the ball, two prominent sight lines milled from the leading edge all the way back provide a track system aesthetically pleasing and extremely functional. The compact size, especially from heel to toe, means it doesn’t look cumbersome, but there’s enough real estate to give you confidence that a mishit will be forgiven - some the most forgiving putters do.

• Read our full Scotty Cameron 2024 Phantom 9 Putter Review

Best large footprint

Finally we have the L.A.B. Golf DF3 mallet which has the largest profile of any putter on this guide. There is good reason for it too from a design perspective. It’s a center-shafted, flat-bottom model that feels very stable and forgiving thanks to "Lie Angle Balance" technology which creates true zero-torque putters, which stay square by themselves. 

Indeed when we tested the putter, these claims did seem to get backed up. We simply just held it lightly, aimed, started our stroke, and let gravity take over. The head, despite being very large, didn't visually distract and we were impressed with how controllable putt speed was. Off-center hits from the heel and toe still made it really close to the target which was great to see and why forgiving putters are designed. Putts sounded rather solid and felt stable, while the sheer size of the head no doubt enhances the forgiveness. The grooves worked well in dampening sound as well. 

Lastly we should mention the customization available on this putter. You can get loads of different colors, head weights, alignment aids, and a whole host of grip and shaft options. 

• Read our full L.A.B. Golf DF3 Putter Review

Best stability

There's no doubt that the PXG Battle Ready Blackjack Putter will split opinions on its loud style that is synonymous with the very unique designs that are also seen on some of the other best PXG golf clubs. Looks aside, this is a very good putter that will help you save shots on the greens. It comes with a host of customization options that help to really dial in your stroke. There are four sole weights on the club's back that can be adjusted to fine-tune the head. They draw the putter's weight to the back to increase forgiveness of the roll of the club. That means you can hit some very sweet putts with this club. 

The variable-sized diamond pattern of the grooves on the face aims to create more speed consistency across a wider area. This works by providing more points of contact away from the center than in the middle, which in turn ensures that the initial velocity of the ball is more consistent. The feel from the face is very good and if you like the sound of golf ball on metal then you won’t be disappointed. We also think the stability on offer is right up there with the best we have tested. 

• Read our full PXG Battle Ready Blackjack Putter Review

How we test putters

When it comes to product testing, our reviews and buyers' guides are built upon a rigorous testing procedure as well as the knowledge and experience of the test team. The putter section is headed up by David Usher, a man with years of gear testing experience especially when it comes to putters. Other members of the Golf Monthly team contribute to the putter tests as well, and all writers are able to efficiently test the vast majority of the biggest product releases and convey the pros and cons eloquently.

Getting into specifics, we test the putters outdoors on real greens with premium golf balls to get a thorough understanding of design features, feel, sound and looks. Ultimately, we aim to be as insightful and honest as possible in our reviews so it is important to acknowledge that no manufacturer can buy a good review. This is because our team tells it how it is. To learn more about our methodology, see how Golf Monthly tests products in our guide. 

How to choose a new putter

The putter is probably the most important club in the bag because it can save so many shots off your scorecard. Therefore there are several factors you need to consider before purchasing a new putter, which we will go into below.

1. Head Design

Putters come in lots of different head designs whether that be blade, mallet, or mid-mallet and all have their positives and negatives. For high handicap golfers, we recommend opting for one of the products on our best mallet putters guide. These clubs tend to be much larger and that helps to improve the forgiveness of the club. This is done through the redistribution of the club's weight towards the extremities of its clubhead, which both stabilizes it and increases the MOI of the putter. 

The higher the MOI, the less your club head will turn through impact, creating a more smooth and even stroke. For that reason, mallet putters typically offer better balance compared to blade putters and are therefore more suitable for less experienced players or those looking for more forgiveness in their club. Additionally, because of this size, mallet putters tend to offer larger sweet spots which are beneficial for players who may struggle to consistently strike the ball. 

2. Feel 

This is a very important factor to consider because when putting, feel is everything. Some putters offer a firmer feel off the face whilst others are soft, some are heavier than others too so you need to find a model that fits well in your hands. The putter grip plays a huge part in the confidence you feel with a putter. Get a putter with a grip that feels right and sits comfortably in your hands while allowing you to return the putter back to the ball squarely and consistently. You may also want to think about the shaft too, for example, think about how much vibration you get from the shaft, whether you like the feel of the ball reverberating along the shaft, or prefer that to be nerfed. 

3. Looks

You have to like what you are putting with because this will give you confidence when you're standing over the ball. In terms of left-handed putters, there are loads of classic and futuristic designs above so it is purely a case of finding a model you like the look of. 

4. Alignment tools

It's also worth thinking about the alignment tools the putter can offer you. While some golfers may not prefer to have any aiming guides on the back of their putters, most players can seriously benefit from having an aiming line on the back of their putter which can also help to improve your focus on the ball and help you strike through the shot more square. 

5. Price 

Our final tip is to think about price because while there are some premium designs out there, there are also some models which offer excellent value, as the selections above show. Sometimes less experienced players should steer clear of the more expensive offerings currently on the market which may actually not be very forgiving and may not be suitable for your swing style.

If you want more advice on forgiving clubs, why not take a look at our guide on the most forgiving drivers or best golf club sets for beginners as well?

FAQs

Rock Bottom Golf coupons

These Rock Bottom Golf coupons will help you save on golf clubs, bags, balls & apparel.

View Deal